Fucking Holocaust
Updated: 2 days ago

From the early eighties to the late teens when I retired as a professor, Holocaust Studies became a thing in academia. A product of identity politics taking root in education generally, along with race, class, gender, sexuality, post-colonial, and other studies, it made sense given the doggedness of the same bigotry that occasioned the historical event, going on a century ago now. There's no end to how such a history can and should be deconstructed. Especially considering the long arc of tyrannical history, religious and otherwise, that created the conditions for such a scene, reaching back millenniums.
Memorials and museums predate Holocaust Studies by several decades. Only two years after WWII ended the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial opened, an early iteration of the Holocaust Memorial it would later become. Then in 1947 the Ghetto Fighters' House Museum opened in a Kibbutz in Israel. In 1953, the year before I was born, Yad Vashem was established; a Holocaust research museum located in Jerusalem. The french instituted Le Mémorial du Martyr Juif Inconnu in 1956, in Paris, and the americans in 1993 opened the doors of the Holocaust Museum in Washington, DC. In 2005 the germans paid homage to the victims of the Holocaust in the Denkmal für die ermordeten Juden Europas near the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, which like the other sites, most of which I've visited, is also eerily moving, and troubling. They are just a few of the roughly 1200 museums and memorials to the Holocaust in the world today.
In no uncertain terms my entire life, and that of my generation, has been framed, shadowed, haunted, and admonished by the events that took place in Europe in the first half of the last century. I was eight when my third grade teacher, Sister Timothy, recounted for us the terrors of the camps and gas chambers. A sensitive child, I doubt I ate supper that day; after all, my early years were spent in a jewish neighborhood in East Cleveland, OH, so jews were friends; family in a real way. I'm sure it's then that scenes from the Holocaust began visiting my dreams in one form or another. I've been having them ever since, including one just two nights ago.
What shocked me most of all when I was a child was the sheer possibility of such unchecked, arbitrary, and murderous power. I had visions, even back then, of government thugs coming to our door and dragging me and my family away. Then when I came out of the closet in 1980, at a coming-out group in Denver, CO, the thing became personal. I learned––for the first time in my life––that queers were also targets of the german government, in the tens of thousands; that they also died in the camps; that it wasn't just jews, only unlike the jews they were reincarcerated by the allies after the war. The Holocaust haunted me in a new way then, in large part because of what I knew about the history of incarcerating queers in the US in my own day, simply for loving. In fact Roma died in the hundreds of thousands too. Communists and the disabled. Largely because they diverged from some fascist ideal; a fact that too often gets overlooked when people get to talking about victims of the horrors.
In 1986 I studied german at the University of Freiburg near the Black Forest; I'd been learning the language for years, along with french, because we vaguely understood back then it was part of our family heritage. While there I met my alsatian relatives, just across the border, in Mulhouse, France. They were so kind and hospitable, and they took me to one of my ancestral homes, in Leymen, France, just along the swiss border. I learned too at the time that my relatives in Alsace offered safe harbor to jews in their basement, endeavoring to slip them across the swiss border at night while evading swiss border guards who weren't fucking around: their orders were to shoot to kill anyone trying to get jews in. They lived in terror that the germans would discover their scheme and haul them all away, a horror that haunted the adults of the time into their old age. One of my relatives, Amélie, was beset by that fear up to her dying day, in 1991, after her mind had become a bit flooey. I fear I'm becoming her.
A few years ago I discovered yet another version of what parents often try to hide from their children, namely the awful roots of generational trauma. I learned that a good chunk of my recent german heritage hadn't set foot in Germany for hundreds of years. They were lured by the Austro-Hungarian Empire to farm a wasteland in what is today the Banat, in Romania. Many jews mingled with christians in what became the breadbasket of Europe in the nineteenth century.* The romanians assumed the territory in 1918 from the hungarians, who'd wrestled it from the austrians in 1868. By WWII, german jews and nonjews had become so integrated that nonjews refused to let jews be deported. In fact Romania was the only european country without a wartime deportation program.
Which isn't to say that jews, along with german christians, weren't imprisoned, particularly after the war; by the russians. Thousands were deported to the Donbas Region by Stalin, and many of my german relatives died in those camps, in a territory Russia and Ukraine are fighting over today. Stalin's justification was the number of communists killed by the germans, as well as what he considered Hitler's double-cross during the war itself; that and his hate for independent farmers, who he referred to as kulaks. The point being the Holocaust came even for ethnic germans who hadn't been in Germany for centuries; includng my own relatives, who no longer spoke Hoch Deutsch and who refused to fight on the german side in the war.
Though my own grandfather got out before the deportations of '48, the events in the Banat haunted him and my father, who was born in the US––I can't help wondering if it contributed to his alcoholism. When two years ago I visited their banatian village, a town once called Moritzfeld that's named Mǎureni today, I was struck by german ghosts everywhere. The romanian orthodox who inhabited their homes after the deportations built new dwellings, leaving the original german homes to become ruins, crumbling adobes dotting the landscape. They built their own orthodox church, and with the catholics gone their old place of worship, St. Martin de Porres, was left to decay; it had a giant padlock on its stately door when my friend and I tried to get in. They plotted their own cemetery as well, away from the germans. The one the Mengays are buried in features tumbled-down stones with their letters fading. A striking feature to me was the fact that on several Mengay markers could still be seen both crosses and stars of David, signifying interfaith marriages.
No doubt the Holocaust began haunting me before I was born. What I don't understand, aside from how it was ever allowed to happen in the first place––by governments and churches both who'd seen the writing on the wall for years––is why its cultural, religious, and political strains haunt us still today; including in the US, the so-called land of freedom and equality. It's again become apparent recently, after an electoral whooping of the perpetrators of some outright hateful policies in the US, on the part of racist ICE agents; a felonious, convicted sex offender of a president; christian nationalist homo- and transphobes; Proud-Boy antisemites and islamophobes––even after an electoral drubbing they've simply doubled down. Most bewildering of all is one of the major perpetrators in the administration's xenophobic campaign, Stephen Miller, is himself a jew. What's more, jews in the US and Israel, along with nonjews, many conservative christians, have openly supported the most recent iteration of the Holocaust, the genocide of gazans, along with the wholesale physical destruction––the flattening––of Gaza itself. You can detest to your toes what happened on October 7th and still recognize that what has ocurred in Gaza is yet another dark tendril of the Holocaust come to back to life; one, I might add, that both Democratic and Republican presidents have helped bankroll.
Fucking Holocaust. When does it end? The naked hatred for the Other? Such an insecure fear of Difference? When will people, every one of us, wake up to the horrors of fascism, finally, say never again––and mean it? The way it makes monsters of humans and seeks to bring down civilization itself?
When will it stop haunting my dreams?
*For a great history of the germans in the Banat I recommend Victor Naumann's important study, The Banat of Timişoara: A European Melting Pot. London: Scala Press, 2019.



Comments